Decide
A ship's master takes the vessel beyond the limits of the professional title. How does Spain's RDL 2/2011 class this, and what is the most serious extra consequence?
The lesson in plain words
- Three grades
- Offences are minor, serious or very serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 305).
- RDL 2/2011 is the Ports and Merchant Marine Act, a Real Decreto Legislativo, which is a decree with the force of law.
- Traffic offences
- Serious traffic offences include breaking the rules on using the national flag (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.3.a), ignoring Capitanía Marítima instructions on manoeuvres and navigation (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.3.e) and breaking the rules on ship clearance (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.3.g).
- Giving false information that must be supplied to the maritime administration is very serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 308.3.e).
- The highest fine is €120,000 if serious and €300,000 if very serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 312).
- Serious safety offences
- Offences against maritime safety carry higher maximum fines: up to €180,000 if serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.2.b).
- Examples are going beyond the limits of a professional or recreational title, or letting someone without enough title act as master or skipper (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.2.h); a crew member acting while impaired by alcohol or drugs (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.2.d); and not reporting a maritime accident or incident (RDL 2/2011, art. 307.2.n).
- Very serious safety offences
- The fine reaches €901,000 (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.3.b).
- Examples are a master or skipper acting while impaired by alcohol or drugs (RDL 2/2011, art. 308.2.i), and a master or crew member who does not give help, or refuses it, when it is requested or seems to be needed (RDL 2/2011, art. 308.2.j).
- Losing the title
- For serious or very serious safety offences, the authority may also suspend the título profesional, the professional title: up to one year if serious, one to five years if very serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.10).
- That article names only the professional title.
- Holding a ship
- RDL 2/2011, art. 320 gives three routes.
- First, the Capitán Marítimo can order it at once, but only to secure the pollution-damage obligations in RDL 2/2011, art. 310.2.d.
- Second, during proceedings for a serious or very serious offence, the body with the power to punish can order it and must give reasons.
- In both cases a sufficient guarantee can replace the holding.
- Third, exceptionally, when retention must take effect at once as a precaution, the Director of the Port Authority may impose it.
Key data
- Serious traffic offence, cap
- €120,000 (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.2.c)
- Very serious traffic offence, cap
- €300,000 (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.3.c)
- Serious safety offence, cap
- €180,000 (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.2.b)
- Very serious safety offence, cap
- €901,000 (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.3.b)
- Title suspension
- Up to 1 year; 1 to 5 years if very serious (RDL 2/2011, art. 312.10)
- Retention of ships
- Three routes (RDL 2/2011, art. 320)
Key points
- Traffic caps: €120,000 serious, €300,000 very serious.
- Safety caps: €180,000 serious, €901,000 very serious.
- Ignoring Capitanía instructions (art. 307.3.e of RDL 2/2011) is a serious traffic offence.
- Failing to give help that is requested or seems needed is a very serious safety offence.
- RDL 2/2011, art. 320: Capitán Marítimo, punishing body, or exceptionally the Port Authority Director.
Check what you have read
What may the Capitán Marítimo secure by holding a ship at once under RDL 2/2011, art. 320?
True or false?
Decide each statement before you see the answer.
All serious offences share one €120,000 cap.
Ignoring Capitanía instructions (art. 307.3.e of RDL 2/2011) is a serious traffic offence.
A held ship must stay held until the proceedings end, whatever the owner offers.
The Capitán Marítimo can hold a ship at once for any offence.
Safety caps: €180,000 serious, €901,000 very serious.
Failing to give help that is requested or seems needed is a very serious safety offence.
Practice case & exam keys
Situation
A master ignores Capitanía instructions on manoeuvres. A month later, the same master takes the ship beyond the limits of the professional title, and proceedings open. The owner fears the ship will be held and offers a bank guarantee. How is each act classed, what are the maximum fines, and does the guarantee help?
Show the answer
Ignoring instructions is a serious traffic offence, up to €120,000 (RDL 2/2011, arts. 307.3.e and 312.2.c). Exceeding the title is a serious safety offence, up to €180,000, and the title may be suspended for up to one year (RDL 2/2011, arts. 307.2.h, 312.2.b and 312.10). During proceedings, the body with the power to punish may hold the ship, giving reasons, and a sufficient guarantee can replace the holding (RDL 2/2011, art. 320).
Exam keys
- Grades of offence: RDL 2/2011, art. 305. Serious traffic offences: RDL 2/2011, art. 307.3.
- Serious safety offences: RDL 2/2011, art. 307.2. Very serious: RDL 2/2011, art. 308.2.
- Caps: RDL 2/2011, art. 312; title suspension in art. 312.10.
- Retention of ships, three routes: RDL 2/2011, art. 320.
