Subject 2 of 9

Collision rules in practice

Most collision questions are one decision: is there a risk, who gives way, and what action is big enough? Decide first, then read why.

Decide

Four situations at sea. Decide first, then read why.

Night, open sea. Fine on your starboard bow: two masthead lights and a red sidelight. Steady bearing. You are power-driven. What do you do?

Key points

  1. Risk firstSteady bearing, closing range: risk exists. If in doubt, it exists.
    1. Lookout by sight, hearing, radar and AIS.
    2. Never decide on scanty radar information.
    3. One large, early alteration, checked until past and clear.
    Radar and collision avoidance
  2. Channels and schemesKeep to the starboard side of a channel; in a scheme, follow the lane.
    1. Join or leave a lane at a small angle; cross at 90° by heading.
    2. Small, sailing and fishing vessels must not impede ships that need the channel or lane.
    3. Do not anchor in a scheme or near its ends.
    TSS and narrow channels
  3. Give-way and stand-onOvertaking keeps clear; head-on both go starboard; crossing, the one with the other to starboard gives way.
    1. Overtaking: from more than 22.5° abaft the beam.
    2. Give-way: early and substantial, don't cross ahead.
    3. Stand-on: hold on, may act, must act when collision is imminent.
    Crossing situations
  4. The pecking orderPower gives way to NUC, RAM, fishing and sail; all avoid impeding a vessel constrained by her draught.
    1. NUC and RAM rank highest.
    2. Sailing gives way to fishing, NUC and RAM.
    3. Fishing vessels keep clear of NUC and RAM.
    Responsibilities between vessels
  5. In fog nobody stands onSafe speed, engines ready, and act early on radar contacts.
    1. Avoid port turns for vessels forward of the beam (unless overtaking).
    2. Avoid turns towards vessels abeam or abaft.
    3. Fog signal forward of the beam: slow to steerage way, stop if needed.
    Restricted visibility

Check what you have read

Question 1/3

The compass bearing of an approaching ship stays the same while the range closes. What does this show?

Worked case: A crossing at night, second mate's watch

0200, clear night, open sea. You are second mate of a 190 m bulk carrier making 12 knots on 000°. Fine on your starboard bow, about 8 miles off, you see a masthead light, a higher masthead light abaft it and a red sidelight. Radar target tracking gives CPA 0.2 miles and TCPA 22 minutes. The compass bearing has stayed at 035° for six minutes.

Before you read the solution: what would you do?

    True or false?

    Decide each statement before you see the answer.

    1. Once the overtaking ship draws level, she becomes a crossing vessel.

    2. As stand-on vessel I must hold course until the moment of impact.

    3. I'll make several small course changes so I don't lose too much time.

    4. Power gives way to NUC, RAM, fishing and sail; all avoid impeding a vessel constrained by her draught.

    5. Overtaking keeps clear; head-on both go starboard; crossing, the one with the other to starboard gives way.

    6. Safe speed, engines ready, and act early on radar contacts.

    7. In fog, the vessel on my starboard side still has to give way.

    8. The bearing is changing a little, so there is no risk of collision.

    9. Steady bearing, closing range: risk exists. If in doubt, it exists.

    10. Inside a traffic separation scheme, ships in the lane have right of way over crossing ships.

    11. Keep to the starboard side of a channel; in a scheme, follow the lane.

    Exercise: Who gives way, and how?

    Work through a crossing and an overtaking in clear weather, then a contact in fog.

    Step by step

    1. A power-driven vessel bears 045° relative from you, bearing steady, closing. Both of you are power-driven and in sight. Who gives way?

    2. What is the best action for you?

    3. You come up on a ship from astern. How many degrees abaft her beam must you be, at least, to be overtaking?

    4. Fog. A radar contact is fine on your port bow, closing to close quarters. Which alteration should you avoid?

    Now on your own

    Now on your own. Each step is a new situation.

    1. You are stand-on. The give-way vessel is closing and still has not acted. What may you do first?

    2. Your ship is crossing a traffic lane. How should you head?

    3. You are power-driven and underway. Ahead is a vessel showing red over white all-round lights (fishing, not trawling). Who keeps clear?

    4. You hear a fog signal apparently forward of the beam. Put your actions in order.

      1. 1Navigate with extreme caution until the danger is over
      2. 2Reduce to the minimum speed to keep your course
      3. 3Take all way off if necessary

    Check: 10 questions

    Questions from this subject, explained after each answer.

    Free: lesson + 10 questions · Exam Pass: all 27 questions, unlimited practice tests, your mistakes retrained

    More on this

    The full explanation and the lessons for each programme item

    Topic 1 of 5

    First find out whether there is a risk

    Rule 5: keep a proper lookout at all times, by sight and hearing and by every available means, such as radar and AIS.

    Rule 6: proceed at a safe speed, one that lets you take proper action and stop within a suitable distance.

    Rule 7: use every means to decide whether risk of collision exists. If the compass bearing of an approaching vessel does not change appreciably, risk exists. It can exist even when the bearing changes, with a very large ship, a tow, or at close range. If in doubt, assume risk exists.

    Do not draw conclusions from scanty information, especially scanty radar information. Plot, or use the radar's target tracking, long enough to be sure.

    • Rule 8: action must be positive, made in ample time and with good seamanship.
    • Make an alteration large enough to be seen at once by eye or radar. A string of small alterations is wrong.
    • If needed, slacken speed, stop or reverse. Check the effect until the other vessel is past and clear.

    Sources

    Checked against the public standards on .